Navigating the Hiring Landscape: In-house Bookkeeping Staff vs. Outsourced Services

The financial health of a business is crucial. Sound bookkeeping and accounting practices are at the heart of this, ensuring that finances are tracked, analyzed, and reported appropriately. However, the process of hiring and maintaining a dedicated in-house team poses several challenges. With the advent of technology and a shift in business models, outsourcing these roles has emerged as a viable alternative. Let’s dive into the intricacies of both these options.

Challenges of Hiring and Maintaining In-house Accounting Staff

  • Recruitment Overhead: Finding the right talent requires time, effort, and financial resources. It involves advertising positions, conducting interviews, and training new employees. There’s also the risk of bad hires, which can be costly.
  • Ongoing Training: Accounting standards, tax regulations, and financial tools evolve. Keeping your team updated requires continual investment in training and professional development.
  • Staff Turnover: The financial sector sees a high turnover rate. When a staff member leaves, it disrupts the workflow, and the recruitment process starts anew. This not only incurs more costs but can also lead to inconsistencies in financial reporting.
  • Overhead Costs: An in-house team means additional fixed costs – salaries, benefits, office space, utilities, and other associated costs.
  • Scalability Concerns: As a business grows, so do its financial complexities. You might need more hands on deck during peak seasons, but having them year-round might not be cost-efficient.

The Ease of Hiring an Outsourced Servicer

  • Cost Efficiency: Outsourcing often leads to cost savings. You pay for the service without the added expenses of recruitment, training, and overhead costs.
  • Access to Expertise: Outsourced service providers are specialists in their domain. They bring a wealth of experience and are updated with the latest in the industry. They often serve multiple clients, giving them a broader perspective on best practices.
  • Flexibility: Outsourced services can be scaled up or down based on your needs. Whether it’s end-of-year reporting or a sudden influx of transactions, they can adapt swiftly.
  • Reduction in Turnover Impact: Relying on an outsourced firm reduces the business risks associated with staff turnover. The service provider ensures continuity and consistent quality.
  • Advanced Technology: Many outsourced service providers have access to the latest accounting tools and software. Businesses can benefit from this without having to invest in and manage these tools themselves.
  • Focus on Core Competencies: Outsourcing non-core tasks like bookkeeping and accounting allows business leaders to focus on growth, strategy, and other critical areas.

High Direct Financial Costs

  • Workshop and Course Fees: Formal training programs, whether online or offline, come with enrollment fees. Specialized courses, particularly those offering certifications or those hosted by reputed institutions, can be particularly pricey.
  • Material and Resources: From textbooks to online resources, the materials required for training aren’t always included in the course fees. Businesses may need to purchase these separately.
  • Software and Tools: With the increasing digitization of accounting, there’s a slew of software and tools that professionals must master. Licenses for these tools, especially premium versions tailored for businesses, can be expensive.

Incalculable Indirect Costs

  • Time is Money: Time spent in training is time away from actual work. For every hour an employee spends in a workshop, that’s an hour not spent on tasks that directly impact the company’s bottom line.
  • Reduced Productivity: Post-training, there’s often a learning curve as employees try to implement their new knowledge or skills. Mistakes might be made, or tasks may take longer as they familiarize themselves with new software or practices.

Opportunity Costs

  • Forgone Opportunities: Time and resources dedicated to training might mean missing out on opportunities like networking events, client meetings, or even just regular day-to-day work that could have led to business growth.
  • Delay in Task Completion: Projects or tasks might be delayed if key personnel are away for training, potentially leading to dissatisfied clients or missed business opportunities.

Retention and Turnover Costs

  • Contrary to what one might think, training can sometimes inadvertently increase turnover. Employees, with their newly acquired skills and certifications, might feel more confident in seeking out better opportunities, leading to recruitment and onboarding costs for the company.

The Middle Ground

  • While the benefits of outsourcing seem numerous, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Some businesses might find comfort in having an in-house team, particularly if they require regular, in-depth financial consultations. For others, especially startups or SMEs with budget constraints, outsourcing could be a boon.

Let’s Provide an in-house accounting specialist vs ProfiPath Costs:

In-House Accounting Staff

  • Base Salary: $50,000
  • Benefits: (typically 20-30% of base salary)
  • Health insurance: $5,000
  • Retirement benefits (e.g., 401k matching): $2,500
  • Paid time off (e.g., vacation, sick leave): $3,000
  • Total Benefits: $10,500
  • Recruitment Costs: (One-time cost often around 20% of base salary)
  • Job posting fees: $500
  • Recruitment agency fees: $10,000
  • Total Recruitment Costs: $10,500
  • Training & Onboarding:
  • Training materials: $500
  • Time spent by other staff for training (estimated $1,000)
  • Total Training & Onboarding: $1,500
  • Workspace & Equipment:
  • Computer & software: $1,500
  • Office space (utilities, rent, etc.): $2,500
  • Total Workspace & Equipment: $4,000

Yearly Total for In-House: $76,500 (First year, considering recruitment costs)

Outsourced Bookkeeper

  • Monthly Service Fee: $1,250-$2,500
  • Yearly Service Fee: $15,000-$30,000
  • Initial Setup Fee: ($0)
  • Software integration, initial consultation, etc.: $0
  • Yearly Total for Outsourced: $15,000-$30,000(First year, considering the setup fee)
  • Comparison:
  • In-House First Year: $76,500
  • Outsourced First Year: $15,000-$30,000

Difference: $61,500 saved in the first year by outsourcing

It’s also worth noting that a hybrid model is gaining traction. Businesses maintain a small in-house team for day-to-day operations but rely on outsourced services for specialized tasks, periodic audits, or during peak seasons.


The decision to hire in-house or outsource is multifaceted. Business size, financial complexity, growth trajectory, and budget all play a role. The key is to understand the challenges and benefits of both approaches and choose one that aligns best with the company’s objectives and resources.

In today’s fast-paced restaurant industry, efficiency, accuracy, and cost-effectiveness are of paramount importance. ProfiPath, with its specialized focus on restaurant bookkeeping and accounting, stands out as a premier solution. Harnessing a combination of industry-specific expertise, technological prowess, and a dedication to client success, ProfiPath ensures that restaurant owners can concentrate on what they do best: serving great food and providing unforgettable experiences.

Moreover, the cost-saving potential when partnering with ProfiPath, as compared to maintaining in-house accounting staff, is undeniable. This isn’t merely about dollars and cents; it’s about the peace of mind that comes with knowing your financial matters are in the hands of specialists who understand the unique challenges and nuances of the restaurant industry. In an era where the margin between success and failure can be razor-thin, leveraging the expertise of a dedicated outsourced service like ProfiPath is not just a strategic move—it’s an essential one. Through its comprehensive suite of services, ProfiPath becomes more than just

Scroll to Top